As can be appreciated, a sizeable amount is usually involved in a commercial let. It is commonplace for both parties to issue cheques to each other, for example, for a security deposit, for a shop in Noida, office space in Delhi, godown space in Ghaziabad and so on. Naturally, difficulties can arise if such a cheque bounces. Action under section 138 of the NI Act, 1881 could ensue as a result of the bouncing of a cheque issued as security deposit. It would turn upon various factors, including the object for which the cheque was issued and the terms of the let, that is, if there was any sum due and payable at the relevant time. By way of illustration: The lessee of a property in South Delhi issues a cheque towards security deposit to the value of Rs 5,00,000/- in terms of the lease deed. The said cheque is dishonoured for want of sufficient funds. Would the lessor be entitled to proceed against the lessee for cheque bounce? It would depend upon various factors. Section 138 may be attracted if there was an amount due and payable to the lessor by way of the security deposit. On the other hand, if the cheque had been given as security only, it would be difficult to say that there was any debt or legally enforceable obligation to pay. It would therefore be prudent for all lessors, lessees and owners to look into the nature and extent of the amount claimed to be due by way of the bounced cheque. Various amounts may be in dispute in a commercial lease, such as rent, security, deductions towards repairs and upkeep, early relinquishment of possession and deterioration of the premises. Each of these issues would have to be considered in its own right. The lessee would contend that there was no obligation or right to present the security cheque, whereas the lessor would say that it was issued towards a particular amount which had fallen due. Each contentions would require careful scrutiny of the relevant documents. It is therefore important to appreciate whether a sum was due and payable, or whether only a security was provided. A large proportion of outgoings for businesses in various cities would be on account of their commercial accommodation. Hiring office space at Nehru Place, shops at Connaught Place, godowns at Ghaziabad, and so on would typically require a sizeable deposit in addition to the monthly rental. Any disagreement in this regard can come in the way of smooth functioning of business and cause much hardship to the landlord as well as the tenant. It is desirable for the landlord to receive the security amount if the tenant is in occupation of the premises. Correspondingly, it would cause great hardship to a tenant if his cheque is deposited by the landlord against a future agreement. It would therefore be prudent to look at the terms of the agreement, payments made and other surrounding facts, advises BK Singh & Associates. Depending upon the facts, the drawer of the cheque could be exposed to action under the NI Act. Questions arising with respect to the tenancy agreement may attract other relief. It is important to distinguish between the various reliefs available. This will arise where a bank returns a cheque provided in respect of a deposit or other sums due under a commercial lease. It will then depend upon the facts as to whether the cheque was given to discharge a debt already due or only to cover a contingent debt. As BK Singh Advocate states, simply characterising a cheque as being held 'as security' is unlikely to be determinative. If a tenant provides a cheque in part in respect of a deposit which falls due on handover, and the debt continues to be outstanding, this could constitute a debt. Alternatively, if the cheque is left with the landlord purely on foot of a potential loss or damage to the property, there may be no corresponding debt. Careful consideration of the terms of the lease and any ancillary material will be required. A landlord can file a case for cheque bounce against their business tenant provided the cheque was drawn in discharge of a legally due debt and other conditions are met. Typically, this will arise when a sum is required as a 'security' on granting of possession to the tenant. Accordingly, if such a cheque bounces, the landlord may wish to explore initiating action under s.138. However, the position is likely different if the landlord has deposited a cheque to meet any potential losses which may arise in the course of the tenancy. BK Singh Advocate suggests drawing a line between: (i) a fixed 'security' due from the tenant on taking up the property; and (ii) a contingent 'security'. The terms of the tenancy and supporting documentation, including timing of possession and payments, will be material. Further, the landlord ought to reflect on whether the figure in question is one to which they are entitled. Rent arrears can give rise to a valid debt. If the lease deed allows a security cheque to be applied to outstanding dues, this could justify a dishonor following crystallization of the debt. However, there will be factors to consider including the terms of the tenancy and the extent of arrears. For example, if a security cheque of Rs. 4L has been issued by the lessee, and he subsequently defaults with a quantified arrears of Rs. 1L, can the full value of the cheque be relied upon to make out a u.s. 138 case? BK Singh Advocate advises reviewing bank records, rent paid vouchers and other credits. It is possible that the figure sought from the tenant is one-sided, contentious (e.g. alleged damages) or otherwise open to question. There will be documentary material which can help to demonstrate the basis for the issue of the cheque, point at which it fell due and if there was an outstanding sum. Such documents may comprise: Evidence of Occupation and Transfer of Possession - may bear on when any deposit should have been paid or repaid. BK Singh Advocate advises that it is best to seek to rely on primary documentary evidence, instead of solely making assertions. Of course, this could take the form of a Deed or other contract; however, other documents may still be material. Proceedings under s. 138 will typically lie with the appropriate criminal court, in accordance with the requirements of s. 142 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. If a cheque is given for encashment into the payee's bank account, the branch of that payee's bank will usually attract territorial jurisdiction under s. 142(2)(a). However, this is not the case where the cheque is deposited or presented for any other reason. It would therefore be prudent to look at the facts relating to the banking arrangement prior to filing a u/s 138 application (as advised by BK Singh Advocate). The fact that the premises in question is a commercial leasehold interest in Delhi, will not require all applications arising out of the said lease to be brought in Delhi. Of course, the position may vary depending on the nature of any accompanying civil action. Often, the parties to a commercial dispute will seek to resolve their matter on a monetary basis rather than continue with the dispute. This may be achievable if there is an identifiable debt and the parties can reach a suitable compromise. The compromise can encompass the debt, any set-offs, future payments and ongoing steps. Under s 147 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, the offences are compoundable. An advocate (BK Singh Advocate) can comment on the consequences of settling and entering into a deed. It is important to note that entering into negotiations does not stay the operation of time-limits or end current proceedings. Any compromise reached should give effect to the debts due and be recorded in the appropriate form. It will often be prudent to seek professional advice if there is any dispute over a significant tenancy bond, a bounced cheque or receipt of a Statutory Demand. The landlord may wish to establish the position as to whether the cheque gives rise to a debt. A tenant may seek information on why a cheque was issued, disagreement over the figure payable under the Tenancy Agreement or claims of breach of contract. An experienced Advocate from BK Singh can review the facts and advise as to the course of action open. Particular care will also be required if the issue arises out of: a company cheque, more than one signatory to the company's bank account, disputes around the expiry of a commercial lease, and concurrent civil and criminal action(s). With respect to company cheques, the requirements imposed by s.141 need to be considered. The mere fact that a person is a Director of the company does not give rise to criminal exposure. The Cheque Bounce Lawyer website details various queries and services offered with respect to bounced cheques, cheque as a security, recovering payments and litigation under the Negotiable Instruments Act 1881. These can include analysis of commercial leases, statutory letters, whether monies are due and any course of action open. If your query pertains to security deposits via cheque, you can contact BK Singh Advocate. Clients from Delhi, New Delhi, Ghaziabad, Noida, Greater Noida, Gurgaon, Faridabad, Meerut, Lucknow, Jaipur, Chandigarh, Mumbai, Pune, Bangalore, Hyderabad, Chennai, Calcutta and Ahmedabad (where applicable and practicable) are welcome to contact us. Further details on the Cheque Bounce Lawyer. A bounced security cheque can give rise to a prosecution u/s 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act provided there is a valid debt and all other prerequisites for invocation of s.138 are met. It will depend on whether the security cheque corresponds to a legally due sum. BK Singh Advocate would advise reviewing the commercial tenancy and payments made. Not necessarily. It will hinge on the nature of the parties' liabilities, background and if any debt had become payable at the time of presenting the cheque. There are various steps the landlord can take. One option would be to proceed with a s.138 proceeding if appropriate. The tenant of course has options to rebut the position taken by the landlord. Depending on the facts, the tenant may seek to dispute the existence, quantum and/or legality of the debt sought to be enforced. Again, this will require corroboration from relevant documents. As mentioned above, the law requires strict adherence to certain conditions. In particular, the landlord will need to serve a valid statutory notice upon the tenant. This is a fact-specific question. However, as noted, it is a prerequisite that a legally enforceable debt exists before a landlord can avail himself of the provisions of s.138. While a landlord may choose to do so, there could be complications if the security cheque does not reflect the actual legally due debt. Parties may agree a settlement that complies with the law. Further, an offence punishable under the NI Act can be compounded pursuant to s.147 of the Act. Any situation involving the return of a security cheque by the tenant, receipt of a statutory notice or disagreement in relation to a commercial tenant's payment(s) would warrant legal advice. If a cheque bounces for the security deposit payable under a commercial tenancy, there will often be significant implications for both the landlord and tenant. This will turn on several factors, including the terms of the lease, the role of the security deposit and whether an actionable debt exists, and the requirements under the Negotiable Instruments Act. Simply providing a security deposit via a cheque will not preclude its operation under s.138; nor will a bounced cheque per se satisfy all of the requisite conditions to attract criminal prosecution. The relevant contracts, accounts and banking correspondence must therefore be closely analysed. Legal advice from BK Singh Advocate will assist you in determining your course of action (or any possible defences) in respect of a commercial lease cheque that has bounced. It is important to seek this advice at the earliest opportunity.Cheque Bounce for Security Deposit in Commercial Lease: What Are Your Legal Rights in India?
Why Do Commercial Lease Security Cheque Disputes Matter in India
Quick Facts About Commercial Lease Security Cheques
What Does Cheque Bounce for Security Deposit in Commercial Lease Mean?
Can a Landlord File a Cheque Bounce Case Against a Commercial Tenant?
Can Outstanding Rent Be Recovered Through a Security Cheque?
Which Documents Are Important in a Commercial Lease Cheque Bounce Case?
Where Can Commercial Lease Cheque Bounce Cases Be Filed?
Can Commercial Lease Cheque Bounce Disputes Be Settled?
When Should You Consult a Cheque Bounce Lawyer?
How Can Cheque Bounce Lawyer Help in Commercial Lease Disputes?
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Will a bounced security cheque result in a criminal offense?
2. Will the landlord be able to initiate a s.138 proceeding against the tenant?
3. Are all security cheques issued by tenants legally actionable?
4. If the tenant's security cheque bounces, what course of action is open to the landlord?
5. How can the tenant raise a defense in a cheque-bounce matter?
6. Do I need to issue a legal notice to meet the requirements of s.138?
7. May the landlord deposit a security cheque with the bank without prior intimation to the tenant?
8. May a security cheque be presented for an amount greater than the unpaid rental due?
9. Are cheque bounce proceedings arising from a commercial tenancy liable to compromise?
10. In what circumstances should I engage BK Singh Advocate?
Final Thoughts
There's no reason for concern. There is no difficult-to-understand legalese.
Someone who has helped many people with the same problems gives you clear, honest advice. We want to make the legal process easy to understand and use for everyone.