Live Chat +91-9811561566
#1 Cheque Bounce After Compromise in DRT: Drafting Safe Payment Terms

Cheque Bounce After Compromise in DRT: Drafting Safe Payment Terms

Learn how cheque bounce after a DRT compromise affects borrowers and creditors, including Section 138 liability, settlement defaults and safer payment terms.

Get A Free Consultation
Cheque Bounce Blogs
NI Act Legal Updates
Cheque Case Guidance
Free Legal Tips

Cheque Bounce After Compromise in DRT: Drafting Safe Payment Terms

Usually, the object of reaching a compromise before the DRT is to put an end to protracted proceedings. On one hand, the borrower would want the banks to desist from further recovering the amount due from him; on the other hand, the bank or financial institution would want to receive dues over such period as may be agreed between the parties. What, therefore, if a cheque given towards this compromise is dishonoured?

Depending upon various factors, action may be open to the parties under section 138 of the NI Act, 1881. It would turn on the nature and terms of compromise reached, existence of a subsisting legally recoverable debt, object for which the cheques were given and satisfaction of other conditions prescribed under the Act.

Assume that a person running a concern enters into a compromise with a bank to pay off the dues over a certain period, giving a number of post-dated cheques. Some of these are honoured by the bank, but one of them is dishonoured for want of sufficient balance.

It is likely that the borrower would take the view that he has honoured some of the cheques and the rest should be covered by the original compromise. The bank, on its part, may deem this to be a default and act accordingly in terms of the compromise.

In addition, it may be able to initiate appropriate action under the NI Act.

BK Singh Advocate would want to scrutinise the terms of the compromise, the cheques and the original debt and other orders of the DRT, if any.

Ideally, no doubt should be left as to what amount and when it is to be paid by the borrower, status and fate of any security created and the effect of any default.

Obviously, if the borrower is imprudent in accepting a time-line for making payments, he runs the risk of further action being commenced against him. Equally, if the lender is careless and agrees to ambiguous terms as to what is payable, it may not be easy for it to prove the exact sum due and payable.

These difficulties would be minimised if adequate provisions are made for all payments to be made by the borrower and what events and action may follow if these are not honoured.

Various aspects relating to a compromise before the DRT and subsequent dishonour of a cheque, provisions of law applicable, desirable clauses, ancillary documents and situations when it would be prudent to seek the assistance of an advocate are discussed here.

Why Cheque Bounce After DRT Compromise Matters in India

These will generally comprise large amounts due and payable to the bank under one or more secured loans, personal guarantees and immovable property.

There are many instances of borrowers opting for compromise in respect of dues and recovery certificate proceedings in the areas of Delhi, NCR, Ghaziabad, Noida, Greater Noida, Gurgaon and Faridabad.

This is equally so in the case of banks based in Mumbai, Pune, Ahmedabad, Jaipur, Chandigarh, Lucknow, Bangalore, Hyderabad, Madras and Calcutta.

Of course, compromise can often be an attractive option for bringing such litigation to an end, but will not necessarily extinguish all consequences flowing from the advance.

If the relevant cheque is dishonoured, there could well be differences of opinion as to the continuance of the original debt, entitlement to the benefit of the compromise and the question of instituting fresh proceedings.

All aspects would be open to consideration by BK Singh Advocate in light of the particular compromise arrived at.

Of particular note would be any term entitling the bank to deprive the debtor of a lesser sum payable by way of compromise upon non-observance of its terms.

Thus a bank may be content to receive a substantially lower figure towards complete discharge of all amounts outstanding, provided this sum is paid on or before certain dates. What happens on breach?

It will again turn on the terms of the compromise and the law applicable to it, as to if and to what extent the original debt will be revived, the sums due and the treatment of sums paid.

Equally, the bank will not necessarily be entitled to recover all sums originally advanced upon any breach.

Quick Facts About DRT Settlement Cheque Bounce

  • Main legislation: Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, mainly ss. 138, 139, 142 and 147.
  • Recovery framework: RDB Act, 1993 (where relevant).
  • Underlying liability: Debt or other liability which is legally enforceable.
  • Notice period: Within 30 days of being informed by the bank of the return of the cheque.
  • Time to pay: Usually 15 days following service of the statutory notice.
  • Filing period: Typically 1 month from the date the cause of action accrues, subject to condonation as per law.
  • Compromise: Any settlement before a DRT will not necessarily quash pending proceedings under s. 138 NI Act.
  • Judicial pronouncements also emphasize the requirement of a legally enforceable debt and proper service of statutory notices.

What Is Cheque Bounce After Compromise in DRT?

A cheque will 'bounce' following a DRT settlement if it is presented for payment and refused. A number of factors will come into play to determine the effect, including but not limited to the terms of the DRT settlement, the use of the cheque, the quantum still outstanding and compliance with any requirements to proceed.

As such, there will be separate issues to consider on a DRT settlement vs a Section 138 cheque bounce.

The DRT has jurisdiction over certain categories of debt recovery disputes against banking and other regulated entities.

On the other hand, a Section 138 claim arises from the non-payment of a cheque given in respect of an existing debt.

Accordingly, one set of facts could give rise to multiple causes of action.

It is possible, for instance, that a creditor will have obtained a valid order to recover a debt and additionally seek to rely on the alleged bounce of a cheque given in settlement.

The fact that a party is pursuing a debt recovery claim does not automatically satisfy each requirement needed to make out a cheque bounce case.

An assessment will need to be conducted by BK Singh Advocate on the debt owing (i.e. the face value of the cheque), the impact (if any) of the DRT settlement on the pre-existing debt and any further payments made in discharge thereof.

This will be especially pertinent if the cheque was provided by way of guarantee, sums had been paid towards the sum in issue or the DRT settlement varied.

Can a Cheque Issued Under a DRT Settlement Attract Section 138?

Yes, subject to the other conditions being met, a DRT compromise cheque could give rise to an action under s.138 if there is a corresponding debt or liability. Merely showing that the cheque arose out of a DRT compromise will not preclude s.138.

This issue is further complicated if the compromise cheque was given as security for subsequent instalments.

It would not be open cut-and-paste to say that a security cheque falls outside the ambit of s.138. It will depend on the circumstances, including whether any debt or liability fell due at the time of presentation.

As discussed above, the SC has accepted that this may occur upon the crystallisation of a particular debt.

Consider therefore a scenario where a debtor gives 4 post-dated cheques in respect of quarterly DRT compromises.

Provided the first 2 instalments have been duly settled, the accounts should show this.

On failure to pay the 3rd instalment, the question then arises as to what (if any) debt or liability is outstanding in relation to the appropriate cheque.

An experienced lawyer such as BK Singh Advocate should be able to advise you.

However, there may be variations in this analysis e.g. some payment has been made, the due date(s) have been varied, the compromise terms altered etc.

What Happens If a Borrower Defaults After a DRT Compromise?

There will be no "one size fits all" answer when considering what happens after a default in respect of a DRT compromise. This will turn on the compromise reached, any directions given by the DRT and the form of debt remaining. In some instances, there could also be scope to initiate further cheque bounce action.

Further Recovery Action

Depending on the compromise and position of the initial claim, there may be further action which can be pursued by the claimant.

As noted above, if the compromise gives rise to a conditional relief, the impact of failure to meet this needs to be considered.

Implications of a Dishonoured Compromise Cheque

On receipt of a returned compromise cheque, the claimant may wish to explore their options under the relevant legislation.

An experienced advocate (e.g. BK Singh Advocate) will be able to advise as to whether a valid debt exists and what pre-requisites need to be fulfilled.

Challenging the Compromise

It is possible that the parties will take differing views as to whether failure to make one instalment within a specified time will cause the whole compromise to fail.

This issue is likely to be more contentious if the wording of the compromise is ambiguous or subsequent correspondence indicates that additional time was granted to comply.

It will not be open to the claimant to automatically impose a wider range of liabilities on the defaultor.

Considerations in relation to Guarantors

If a guarantor has issued a cheque(s) or otherwise made themselves liable to effect the compromise, further issues will arise.

For example, the issue of a Section 138 liability where the cheque has been issued by the guarantor, having rendered themselves liable to satisfy the compromise.

The Supreme Court has held that the legislative reference to a person being 'liable' or owing a 'debt' can go wider than the initial debt owed by the borrower.

What Documents Are Important After Dishonour of a Settlement Cheque?

This will often be material if the issue arises in relation to a prior recovery and later compromise. The following types of document may therefore be pertinent:

  • Loan and sanction papers.
  • DRT petition, order(s) and certificate(s) of recovery.
  • Compromise executed between the parties.
  • Bank's intimation of sanction/OT.
  • Installment list and current dues.
  • Cheques issued pursuant to the compromise.
  • Memo(s) of returned cheques and bank records.
  • Evidence of previous receipts.
  • Letters relating to any extension and consequential liabilities.
  • Statutory demands and replies thereto.
  • Any guarantees given.
  • Documentation as to abandonment of action etc.
  • Obviously, some or all of the above need not apply in each instance.

The BK Singh Advocate can advise on the documentation required in respect of the liability in question, and compare this with the position as reflected in the books of the respective parties.

It is advisable that original papers be retained and neither party makes assertions as to the quantum due or consequences of the compromise without supporting basis.

When Should You Consult a Cheque Bounce Lawyer?

It would be prudent to take legal advice prior to entering into any significant DRT compromise, for example if there are post-dated cheques, individual and/or property security, or other terms and conditions attached to the compromise.

This will become even more critical once a cheque bounces.

As noted above, there are tight time limits imposed on each party by statute, which are not affected by any dealings with the other party.

BK Singh Advocate would be able to consider the face of the cheque(s), any accompanying return memo, compromise documentation and correspondence, and highlight the pertinent points.

Depending on the circumstances, a borrower may wish to take advice in relation to their exposure, potential defenses, varying the compromise, and any current adjudication.

A creditor may wish to take advice if the compromise has lapsed, they disagree with the sum owing or the validity of the compromise.

Finally, an advocate can comment as to the commerciality of continuing with a given course of action.

How Can Cheque Bounce Lawyer Assist With DRT Settlement Disputes?

Any business, borrower, lender or third party (e.g. guarantor) who faces bounced settlement cheque(s) and associated problems can approach a Cheque Bounce Lawyer.

An experienced lawyer at BK Singh Advocate will be able to examine any outstanding loan related files, DRT Compounds, Dishonoured Cheque files, Contractual Exposure and Statutory Notices.

Some of these questions could form part of the advice provided:

  • Does the Settlement Cheque constitute a valid debt?
  • Are previous disbursements relevant to the outstanding claim?
  • Has any breach triggered further action pursuant to the DRT Compound?
  • Are any actions currently sub-judice?
  • Is it possible to compound/settle the matter?

It should be noted that no legal practitioner can assure the client of recovering a debt, quashing a case, getting a settlement accepted or escaping prosecution.

This will depend on the facts of each case.

Clients (individuals and corporate) based in Delhi-NCR and elsewhere in India can contact an Advocate to discuss their situation.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Is it possible to have a cheque bounce after a DRT compromise?

There is potential for a Section 138 action to lie following a DRT settlement, depending upon whether there is a legal obligation to pay and other conditions being met. This can be considered with reference to the DRT settlement and any cheque(s) returned.

2. Will my current Section 138 case be discontinued on a DRT settlement?

Not necessarily. Further consideration will be required as to how (if at all) the criminal complaint can be withdrawn, disposed of or compounded.

3. Could I be made liable on a 'security' cheque?

In principle, yes. If the obligation to which the security relates has fallen due, then the 'security' cheque could give rise to a Section 138 action, subject to the terms of the arrangement and any prior payments made.

4. If I fail to make a DRT settlement payment, what will happen?

This will turn on the wording of the compromise and any court directions made. It may lead to a simple disagreement, difficulties in realizing further sums, or trigger a contractual penalty provision.

5. If I default on a DRT compromise, can the Bank demand repayment of the full loan?

Again, this will depend on the DRT compromise, the position of the debt, any monies received and any other legal considerations. In all cases, it will not simply entitle the Bank to recover the initial facility sum.

6. Will the Bank be able to issue cheques against my guarantor(s)?

If a cheque has been given in respect of a legal debt, then provided the necessary elements are fulfilled, the guarantor(s) may be exposed to a Section 138 action. BK Singh Advocate can review the relevant documents.

7. How soon must a section 138 demand notice be served?

The recipient of a cheque has 30 days from the date that they learn of its return by the Bank, to serve the requisite notice on the drawer.

8. Once a Section 138 case is commenced, can it still be compromised?

Subject to meeting the prerequisites, the NI Act allows a compromise (Section 147). Care must be taken that the resolution adequately resolves the outstanding issues.

9. Can I continue to be pursued under the DRT as well as a Section 138 action?

In general, yes. The two actions pursue distinct courses and need to be viewed on their own merits. However, no party should be able to obtain double satisfaction for the same sum.

10. Should I seek legal input before agreeing to DRT payments?

It would be prudent to ensure that the liability is correctly stated, along with the quantum, payment schedule, any collateral and implications of non-payment. BK Singh Advocate can look at the accounts and any live litigation.

Final Thoughts

A DRT compromise will ideally remove ambiguity as to what is payable, or allow the issue(s) between the parties to be resolved.

If unclear, however, this may lead to contention over breach, debt due, PD cheques, further court action etc.

Dishonour of a cheque following a DRT compromise needs careful consideration, given that the issue will likely become distinct from the underlying DRT case.

Accordingly, the DRT compromise should seek to address all key points of indebtedness and any courses of action open to the relevant party.

BK Singh Advocate can assist with issues relating to DRT compromises, dishonoured cheque(s), u/s 138 proceedings and other associated contract issues.

It is important that debtors, sureties and creditors take appropriate steps at the earliest opportunity.

Author Bio

BK Singh Advocate provides legal opinion on issues pertaining to bounces, money recovery, business contracts and similar causes of action. Specifically, he can provide guidance with respect to s.138 NI Act, any matter arising from or connected to a compromise, payments due under a contract and money recovery.

When approaching BK Singh Advocate, a client will be assisted to consider their agreement(s), supporting documentation, potential pitfalls and courses of action open to them. This may apply where the client is a borrower, lender, surety or company.

He will accept instructions from parties located anywhere within Delhi NCR and India for a tailored opinion dependent upon the facts and documents provided.

There's no reason for concern. There is no difficult-to-understand legalese.

Someone who has helped many people with the same problems gives you clear, honest advice. We want to make the legal process easy to understand and use for everyone.

 +91-9811561566 Chat on WhatsApp